
Shop All Cookies
Filters
- Cookies Remove filter
- Clear all
- Cookies Remove filter
- Clear all
-
Save up to 0% Save %
Jack-O-Lantern Smiley Cookie
Original price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Trick or treat yourself to these Jack-O-Lantern Smiley Cookies! Starting with a base of smooth orange icing, these eerie-sistible cookies come top...
View full detailsOriginal price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mini Jack-O-Lantern Smiley Cookie
Original price $21.99 - Original price $129.99Original price$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99These Mini Jack-O-Lantern Smiley Cookies are perfect for trick-or-treaters! Starting with a base of smooth orange icing, these eerie-sistible cook...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $129.99Original price$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mummy Smiley Cookie
Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99Original price $19.99$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Everyone is eager to unwrap our Mummy Cookies! Starting with a base of smooth white icing, these cookies come hand-decorated to put a Smile on you...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $19.99Original price $19.99$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mini Mummy Smiley Cookie
Original price $19.99 - Original price $129.99Original price $19.99$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99Everyone is eager to unwrap our new Mini Mummy Cookies! Starting with a base of smooth white icing, these cookies come hand-decorated to put a Smi...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $129.99Original price $19.99$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Monster Smiley Cookie
Original price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price $20.99$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99You’ll want to keep an eye on our Monster Smiley Cookies—they’re always up for a sweet scare! These little beasties come hand-decorated in green i...
View full detailsOriginal price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price $20.99$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mini Monster Smiley Cookie
Original price $21.99 - Original price $129.99Original price $21.99$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99You’ll want to keep an eye on our Mini Monster Smiley Cookies—they’re always up for a sweet scare! These little beasties come hand-decorated in gr...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $129.99Original price $21.99$21.99 - $129.99$21.99 - $129.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Fall Smiley Cookie
Original price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99You're sure to fall for these Smiles! Our Fall Smiley Cookies come hand-decorated in autumn colors, including white faces on red, gold, and orange...
View full detailsOriginal price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Fall Mini Smiley Cookie
Original price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99They may be half the size, but our Fall Mini Smiley Cookies shine just as brightly as our classic round cookies! The Mini Fall Smiley Cookies come...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Original Smiley Cookies
Original price $19.99 - Original price $64.99Original price$19.99 - $64.99$19.99 - $64.99Current price $19.99The one that started it all! It’s the snack that takes you back to the childhood sensation of earning a sweet treat at the end of your meal. For m...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $64.99Original price$19.99 - $64.99$19.99 - $64.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Uniced Classic Round Cookies
Original price $11.99 - Original price $46.99Original price$11.99 - $46.99$11.99 - $46.99Current price $11.99Uniced tastes just as nice! Create your own Smiles at home with these Uniced 4” Round sugar cookies, freshly baked and ready to be decorated any wa...
View full detailsOriginal price $11.99 - Original price $46.99Original price$11.99 - $46.99$11.99 - $46.99Current price $11.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Rainbow Smiley Cookies
Original price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Color the world in Smiles! Our Smiley Cookie is decked out in vibrant colors of the rainbow and topped with our iconic Smile. Sure to make even the...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Gold Star Cookies
Original price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Whether it’s a good report card or a job well done, excellence merits deliciousness with our Gold Star Cookies. Each star-shaped sugar cookie is ha...
View full detailsOriginal price $20.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$20.99 - $74.99$20.99 - $74.99Current price $20.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Graduation Smiley Cookie
Original price $19.99 - Original price $71.99Original price$19.99 - $71.99$19.99 - $71.99Current price $19.99Cap off graduation parties and other commencement festivities with our Graduation Smiley Cookies! Formed in the shape of a graduate wearing a gradu...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $71.99Original price$19.99 - $71.99$19.99 - $71.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Classic White Round Cookies
Original price $14.99 - Original price $52.99Original price$14.99 - $52.99$14.99 - $52.99Current price $14.99Create your own Smiles at home with these White 4” Round sugar cookies, hand-iced with white icing. Whether for decorating cookies by yourself or w...
View full detailsOriginal price $14.99 - Original price $52.99Original price$14.99 - $52.99$14.99 - $52.99Current price $14.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Smiley Heart Cookie
Original price $19.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$19.99 - $74.99$19.99 - $74.99Current price $19.99Share your heart—and Smile—with someone special! Our heart-shaped Smiley Cookie is hand-iced with smooth pink icing and topped with our iconic Smil...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$19.99 - $74.99$19.99 - $74.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Black and Gold Mini Smiley Cookies
Original price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99Yeah, you know what it is! Black and yellow, black and yellow, black and yellow. Did you know that Pittsburgh is the only U.S. city where all its m...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mini Smiley Heart Cookie
Original price $22.99 - Original price $45.99Original price$22.99 - $45.99$22.99 - $45.99Current price $22.99Share your heart—and Smile—with someone this Valentine’s Day! Our mini heart-shaped Smiley Cookie is hand-iced with smooth pink icing and topped wi...
View full detailsOriginal price $22.99 - Original price $45.99Original price$22.99 - $45.99$22.99 - $45.99Current price $22.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Baseball & Softball Cookies
Original price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Knock your snack game out of the park with our Baseball & Softball Cookies! Whether for team sports or for a game-time snack at home, these coo...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save 0% Save %
Mini Smiley Cookie Snack Bag
Original price $21.99 - Original price $21.99Original price$21.99$21.99 - $21.99Current price $21.99Pass the bag and share a Smile with our Mini Smiley Cookie Snack Bag! The pack includes 24 Original Mini Smiley Cookies—freshly baked, hand-iced an...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $21.99Original price$21.99$21.99 - $21.99Current price $21.99Save 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Uniced Star Cookies
Original price $12.99 - Original price $49.99Original price$12.99 - $49.99$12.99 - $49.99Current price $12.99Make your decorating skills the star of the kitchen with our Uniced Star Cookies! Create your own Smiles at home with these star-shaped sugar cooki...
View full detailsOriginal price $12.99 - Original price $49.99Original price$12.99 - $49.99$12.99 - $49.99Current price $12.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Uniced Heart Cookies
Original price $12.99 - Original price $49.99Original price$12.99 - $49.99$12.99 - $49.99Current price $12.99Decorate to your heart’s content with our Uniced Heart Cookies! Create your own Smiles at home with these heart-shaped sugar cookies, freshly baked...
View full detailsOriginal price $12.99 - Original price $49.99Original price$12.99 - $49.99$12.99 - $49.99Current price $12.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Red Sugar Sparkle Heart Cookies
Original price $19.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$19.99 - $74.99$19.99 - $74.99Current price $19.99Make someone’s heart flicker with our Red Sugar Sparkle Heart Cookies! Bursting with joy that’s sure to brighten anyone’s day, these heart-shaped c...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $74.99Original price$19.99 - $74.99$19.99 - $74.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Pirate Smiley Cookies
Original price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Argh, matey! Our Black & Gold Pirate Cookies are something any devoted Pirate fan will want to plunder for tailgate parties or as a gametime sn...
View full detailsOriginal price $19.99 - Original price $69.99Original price$19.99 - $69.99$19.99 - $69.99Current price $19.99Save up to 0% Save % -
Save up to 0% Save %
Mini Basketball Cookies
Original price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99These Mini Basketball Cookies dribble with deliciousness! Hand-iced with smooth orange icing and lined in black like the seams of a basketball, our...
View full detailsOriginal price $21.99 - Original price $44.99Original price$21.99 - $44.99$21.99 - $44.99Current price $21.99Save up to 0% Save %