Skip to content
Share a Smile with a Gift Card!
Share a Smile with a Gift Card!

Original Smiley Cookies

Original price $20.99 - Original price $79.99
Original price
$20.99 - $79.99
Current price $20.99

 The one that started it all! It’s the snack that takes you back to the childhood sensation of earning a sweet treat at the end of your meal.

For more than 50 years, the bakers at Warner’s Bakery would awaken Titusville, Pa., residents with the sweet smell of morning pastries like doughnuts, pies, Danishes. . .and a special sugar cookie adorned with a colorful, smiling face. One of those residents was Jim Broadhurst, future CEO of the Pittsburgh-based restaurant chain Eat’n Park, which originally opened as a carhop in 1949 and today has restaurants in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia. 

 In 1986, Broadhurst launched a new menu item at Eat’n Park: the Smiley Cookie. Now guests could experience the sweet, simple taste of his go-to childhood snack, with all children receiving a free Smiley Cookie after their meal at every Eat’n Park restaurant. Soon, the recognizable cookie face would become an unofficial Pittsburgh mascot across the region.  

The Original Smiley Cookie features our iconic smile hand-iced on a freshly baked sugar cookie. From special events to gifts, at home or the office, make any place a place for Smiles.

 These cookies are:

  • Decorated by hand with sweet icing by our cookie artists
  • Freshly baked sugar cookies
  • 4” in dimension
  • Made in a 100% nut-free facility (peanut and tree nut free)
  • Certified Kosher (OU – Dairy)
  • Individually wrapped, perfect for sharing a Smile

Schedule your cookies for future delivery date or have them shipped out ASAP! Either way, your cookies will be fresh-baked and hand-iced! Because of our commitment to provide freshly baked cookies that create Smiles, our Smiley Cookies typically ship out approximately 3 days after the date they are ordered, unless otherwise specified. At checkout, simply use our calendar feature to select the day when you would like your order to be delivered. If you are planning an event, we recommend setting a delivery date of 3 to 4 business days BEFORE your event to avoid any unexpected delays from UPS. 

Choose a Pack Size